Why running your SCUBA cylinder too low is a dumb idea.
Why do SCUBA divers run their cylinder dangerously low?
In this blog post, we will explore the dangers associated with diving with a cylinder below 50 bar and the importance of maintaining a conservative air supply.
The reason for this blog post is to highlight the risks associated with poor gas managment and through education, hopefully we can erase this dangerous practice from the next generation of SCUBA divers.
In all our years or professional diving around the globe, Aotearoa (New Zealand) is by far the worst country we have worked in that continues this outdated dangerous practice.
Aotearoa also has the worst safety record, when it comes to SCUBA diving related accidents, of any country we have worked in - there may be a a direct correlation between the two points raised above.......make yourself a cup of tea and read on...
Firstly why do people do it? The reason for this is two fold.
If we look back historically at SCUBA diving within Aotearoa, the sport started to become popular during the 1960's and certainly back then it would have been much more difficult to get a cylinder filled due to the lack of scuba compressors available, therefor due to this, divers may have adopted the mindset of "use of much of your available air as the next fill is many miles away".
Thankfully due to the rise in popularity of diving within Aotearoa, you will easily find a dive centre or cylinder fill station near you that will replenish your depleted cylinder. There are even mainstream retail stores and garages that will offer fills although we would always recommend getting your fills at a proper dive centre (they know what they are doing when it comes to high pressure gas and compressor systems).
The second reason for "old school" divers running cylinders too low was poor or no education of safe diving practices. Again back in the day there were far less dive centres with dive professionals able to teach correct and safe diving, this lead to a mindset of learning from a family member or friend and guess what? This of course leads to unsafe diving practices following advice from someone who is definitely not an experienced and certified professional dive educator.
Again we are lucky to now have many professional dive centres situated right across the country, all offering a variety of professional training programs, so there is no excuse not to get yourself properly and professionally trained and certified.
Scuba diving offers unparalleled adventures beneath the waves, but it also comes with its own set of risks. One significant danger that divers may encounter is running a scuba cylinder—commonly incorrectly referred to as a "tank" - below 50 bar (approximately 725 psi). While it's essential for divers to monitor their air supply closely, going below this threshold can lead to several critical safety issues, including:
1. Increased Risk of Running Out of Air
When a diver descends to greater depths, they're air consumption increases due to higher ambiant pressure and with physical exertion this can further deplete remaining gas supplies. As the dive progresses, air supply can become depleted more quickly than anticipated and without proper planning and training you can quickly be in a life threatening situation (emergency). Running a tank below 50 bar significantly heightens the risk of running out of air while still underwater, leaving the diver vulnerable to emergency situations. For the untrained diver out of gas whist still underwater, attempting to ascend without following safe emergency protocols can easily lead to an embolism resulting is stroke, paralysis and death, not a good end to the days diving huh? (again GET PROFESSIONAL TRAINING if you're currently untrained.
2. Limited Time for Ascent
If a diver is low on air, especially below the 50-bar mark, they may not have enough time to complete a safe and slow ascent, including necessary safety decompression stops. A safe ascent is crucial for all divers to allow excess nitrogen to exit the body in a controlled, safe manner and minimise the risks of decompression sickness (DCS). Insufficient air can lead to a rushed ascent, increasing the chance of developing DCS symptoms, which can have severe health consequences and risk to life.
3. Difficulty Managing Emergencies
Diving can be unpredictable, and emergencies may arise that require additional air supply, for example; searching for a missing diver. This could also include helping a buddy in distress, dealing with equipment failure, or encountering a sudden current. If a diver is operating with less than 50 bar, there may not be enough air to address these emergencies adequately, leading to potentially life-threatening situations for both the diver and their buddy.
4. Inadequate Awareness of Actual Air Supply
As a diver approaches 50 bar, the pressure gauge becomes less reliable, and divers may misestimate how much air is left in the tank. Additionally, the diminishing sound of the cylinder and the psychological stress of being low on air can lead to panic, further impairing decision-making skills and situational awareness.
5. Equipment Failure Risks
Operating below 50 bar can increase the risks associated with equipment failure. In lower-pressure situations, regulators may begin to function poorly, leading to difficult or even failed air delivery. If a diver’s regulator malfunctions at low pressures, it can create a critical air supply issue when it's needed most.
6. Safety Protocol Breaches
Diving organisations and training agencies typically recommend that divers do not go below a certain pressure (often around 50 bar) to help ensure safety. Disregarding these protocols can indicate a lack of training, poor planning, or negligence, which can lead to dangerous situations and even accidents.
Prevention Strategies
To mitigate the risks associated with running a scuba cylinder below 50 bar, divers should adopt the following best practices:
Monitor Air Supply: Regularly check the pressure gauge throughout the dive to keep aware of how much air is left.
Plan Your Dives: Work out your dive plan, considering depth, time underwater, and air consumption rates to avoid low air situations.
Use the Rule of Thirds: A good practice is to use one-third of your air for the descent, one-third for your ascent, and one-third as a reserve. This allows for unexpected situations that might arise during the dive.
Ascend with Reserve: Aim to ascend with at least a 50-bar reserve to allow for a safe ascent and safety stops.
Communicate with Buddies: Constantly communicate air supply levels with dive buddies and maintain good situational awareness throughout the dive.
